100 thoughts on “House Impeachment Inquiry Hearing – Feldman, Karlan, Gerhardt & Turley Testimony”

  1. I have voted for both parties based on the candidate. After watching the democrats over the last seven years ( especially the last three years) , I will no longer vote for a democrat. The democrats have lost their minds.

  2. 37:28 Order-ish

    38:31 Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-NY) – Rules

    39:14 Rep. Nadler, Opening statement

    49:30 Rep. Doug Collins (R-GA) – Opening statement

    1:04:37 Rep. Nadler, intro to the witnesses

    1:07:17 Rep. Nadler, swearing in

    1:09:00 Noah Feldman, Harvard Law School Opening statement

    1:21:32 Pamela Karlan, Stanford Law Professor Opening statement

    1:30:34 Michael Gerhardt, Univ. of North Carolina Law Professor Opening statement

    1:41:10 Jonathan Turley, George Washington Univ. Law Professor Opening statement

    1:54:08 Rep. Nadler, first round of questions (1:54:52, Prof. Karlan)(1:55:34, Prof. Gerhardt)(1:56:38, Prof. Feldman)

    1:57:54 Norman Eisen, Democratic Counsel (1:58:16, Feldman)(1:59:12, Karlan)(1:59:22, Gerhardt)(1:59:46, Feldman, 2:00:03, Karlan, 2:00:08, Gerhardt)(2:00:36, Feldman)(2:02:34, Karlan)(2:05:03, Gerhardt)(2:05:30, Prof. Turley)(2:06:07, Feldman, Karlan, Gerhardt)(2:06:26, Feldman)(2:06:55, Karlan)(2:12:52, Feldman)(2:15:28, Gerhardt)(2:16:13, Karlan)(2:16:53, Feldman, Gerhardt)(2:17:03, Karlan)(2:23:44, Feldman, 2:24:37, Gerhardt)(2:25:46, All Profs. 2:26:12, Feldman. 2:26:53, Karlan. 2:28:28, Gerhardt.)(2:29:57, Gerhardt. 2:30:40, Karlan.)(2:31:03, Feldman. 2:32:19, Pres. Trump. 2:32:37, Gerhardt.)(2:33:42, Gerhardt)(2:35:56, Karlan)(2:37:54, Feldman)

    2:39:21 “Humanitarian Recess”

    2:59:40 Order

    2:59:57 Rep. Doug Collins (R-GA) First round of questions.(3:02:57, Turley)(3:16:54, Turley)(3:17:07, Turley)(3:18:20, Turley)(3:19:23, Collins)(3:20:42, Turley)(3:21:37, Collins)(3:22:12, Turley)(3:23:25, Collins)

    3:25:25 Paul Taylor, Republican Counsel

    (3:26:20, Turley)(3:28:09, Taylor)(3:29:50, Turley)(3:32:26, Taylor)(3:33:19, Turley)(3:34:21, Turley)(3:35:15, Taylor)(3:36:41, Turley)(3:37:14, Taylor)(3:39:50, Turley)(3:40:45, Taylor)(3:41:14, Turley)(3:41:39, Turley)(3:42:48, Turley)(3:43:30, Taylor)(3:43:59, Turley)

    3:45:24 White House, invitation declined.

    3:45:37 Rep. Nadler (3:45:43, Feldman)(3:46:47, Feldman)(3:47:08, Gerhardt)(3:48:06, Gerhardt, 3:48:55, Karlan)(3:49:52, Feldman)

    3:50:41 Rep. Collins (3:51:27, Turley)(3:54:11, Collins)

    3:55:45 Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-CA) (3:57:52, Karlan)(3:58:39, Gerhardt)(3:59:31, Lofgren)(3:59:57, Feldman)(4:00:24, Lofgren)

    4:00:50 Recess. (4:05:01, Democratic representatives. 4:16:53, call-ins. 4:24:18, Pres. Trump. 4:34:21, call-ins.)

    5:14:27 Order.

    5:14:54 Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-WI) (5:19:03, Turley)

    5:20:11 Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee (D-TX) (5:20:59, Karlan)(5:21:50, Karlan)(5:22:40, Feldman)(5:23:16, Karlan)(5:23:30, Col. Vindman)(5:23:58, Feldman)(5:24:27, Jackson Lee)

    5:25:17 Rep. Steve Chabot (R-OH)

    5:30:23 Rep. Steve Cohen (D-TN) (5:31:23, Feldman)(5:32:28, Karlan, Feldman, Gerhardt)(5:32:47, Feldman, Gerhardt)(5:33:01, Karlan. 5:33:41, Feldman. 5:34:03, Gerhardt.)(5:34:44, Turley)

    5:35:33 Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-TX)

    5:40:42 Rep. Hank Johnson (D-GA) (5:40:51, Karlan)(5:41:19, Karlan)(5:41:44, Feldman)(5:42:46, Feldman)(5:43:49, Feldman)(5:44:51, Karlan)(5:45:29, Johnson)

    5:45:49 Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH)

    5:50:34 Rep. Ted Deutch (D-FL) (5:51:37, Feldman)(5:52:10, Gerhardt)(5:52:36, Karlan)(5:53:14, Karlan)(5:54:00, Deutch)

    5:55:32 Rep. Ken Buck (R-CO) (5:55:39, Turley)

    6:00:41 Rep. Karen Bass (D-CA) (6:00:58, Gerhardt)(6:02:10, Holmes)(6:02:31, Feldman)(6:03:01, Karlan)(6:03:39, Bass)

    6:05:15 Rep. John Ratcliffe (R-TX) (6:07:09, Turley)(6:07:24, Turley)(6:08:01, Turley)(6:08:21, Turley)(6:10:09, Turley)

    6:10:23 Rep. Cedric Richmond (D-LA) (6:12:03, flashback footage) (6:12:37, Feldman)(6:13:09, Karlan)(6:14:01, Feldman. 6:14:23, Karlan. 6:14:44, Gerhardt)(6:15:04, Richmond)

    6:15:30 Rep. Martha Roby (R-AL) (6:15:30, Turley) (6:16:08, Roby)

    6:20:33 Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) (6:21:17, Karlan)(6:21:52, Karlan)(6:22:26, Karlan)(6:22:35, Karlan)(6:22:43, Karlan)(6:22:52, Karlan)(6:23:09, Jeffries)(6:23:44, Taylor flashback)(6:24:08, Karlan)(6:24:31, Karlan)(6:24:43, Jeffries)

    6:25:38 Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL) (6:26:11, Gerhardt)(6:26:53, Feldman)(6:27:33, Feldman)(6:27:41, Feldman)(6:28:04, Karlan)(6:28:29, Karlan)(6:28:41, Karlan)(6:28:58, Karlan)(6:29:19, Gaetz)(6:30:00, all witnesses)

    6:31:04 Rep. David Cicilline (D-RI) (6:31:04, Feldman)(6:31:38, Gerhardt)(6:32:08, Karlan)(6:33:04, Feldman)(6:33:54, Cicilline)(6:35:07, Feldman. 6:35:49, Karlan)

    6:36:16 Rep. Mike Johnson (R-LA)

    6:41:24 Rep. Eric Swalwell (D-CA) (6:41:41, Turley)(6:42:18, Swalwell)(6:43:47, Taylor flashback)(6:44:14, Karlan)(6:44:39, Karlan)(6:45:17, Karlan)(6:46:01, Feldman)

    6:46:45 Recess

    7:02:51 Order

    7:02:58 Rep. Andy Biggs (R-AZ)

    7:08:22 Rep. Ted Lieu (D-CA) (7:09:19, Feldman)(7:10:19, Karlan)(7:11:11, Sondland/Taylor flashbacks)(7:11:47, Sondland flashback)(7:12:12, Karlan)(7:12:44, Lieu)

    7:13:27 Rep. Tom McClintock (R-CA) (7:14:42, Turley)(7:15:41, Turley)(7:17:01, Turley)(7:17:28, Turley)(7:17:43, Turley)(7:18:14, Turley)

    7:19:00 Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD) (7:19:56, Karlan)(7:20:12, Feldman)(7:20:48, Raskin)(7:21:45, Feldman)(7:22:23, Karlan)(7:23:21, Feldman, Gerhardt, Karlan)(7:23:49, Feldman, Karlan, Gerhardt)

    7:24:13 Rep. Debbie Lesko (R-AZ)

    7:29:26 Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) (7:30:32, Williams flashback)(7:30:44, Karlan)(7:30:51, Karlan)(7:31:12, Karlan)(7:31:59, Karlan)(7:32:15, Karlan)(7:33:04, Karlan)(7:33:49, Karlan)(7:34:11, Jayapal)

    7:34:52 Rep. Guy Reschenthaler (R-PA) (7:38:50, Turley)

    7:40:16 Rep. Val Demings (D-FL) (7:42:06, Gerhardt)(7:42:20, Gerhardt)(7:42:55, Gerhardt)(7:43:01, Feldman)(7:43:28, Gerhardt)(7:44:01, Gerhardt)(7:44:29, Demings)

    7:45:20 Rep. Ben Cline (R-VA)

    7:49:51 Rep. Ratcliffe (7:49:51, Turley)

    7:51:08 Rep. Lou Correa (D-CA) (7:51:28, Feldman)(7:51:57, Feldman)(7:52:42, Feldman)(7:53:30, Gerhardt)(7:54:06, Correa)

    7:55:54 Rep. Kelly Armstrong (R-ND)

    7:59:30 Rep. Jordan (7:59:30, Karlan)(7:59:35, Jordan)(7:59:56, Karlan)(8:00:04, Jordan)

    8:01:02 Rep. Mary Gay Scanlon (D-PA) (8:02:42, Gerhardt)(8:03:31, Gerhardt)(8:03:40, Feldman)(8:04:08, Feldman)(8:04:46, Feldman)(8:04:54, Scanlon)

    8:07:17 Rep. Sylvia Garcia (D-TX) (8:08:51, Gerhardt)(8:09:31, Gerhardt)(8:10:00, Gerhardt)(8:10:21, Garcia)

    8:11:45 Rep. Joe Neguse (D-CO) (8:14:08, Gerhardt)(8:14:58, Turley)(8:15:14, Turley)(8:15:26, Turley)(8:15:30, Turley)(8:15:39, Turley)(8:15:46, Turley)(8:16:00, Turley)

    8:17:02 Rep. Lucy McBath (D-GA) (8:17:53, Yovanovitch flashback) (8:18:52, Gerhardt) (8:19:58, McBath)

    8:20:49 Rep. Greg Stanton (D-AZ) (8:21:46, Gerhardt) (8:22:16, Feldman)(8:23:02, Gerhardt)(8:23:49, Karlin)(8:24:16, Stanton)

    8:25:12 Rep. Greg Steube (R-FL) (8:28:30, Nadler)

    8:28:56 Rep. Ratcliffe (8:29:00, Turley)

    8:30:18 Rep. Madeleine Dean (D-PA) (8:31:45, Karlan)(8:32:17, Feldman)(8:33:17, Gerhardt)(8:34:17, Dean)

    8:35:25 Rep. Debbie Mucarsel-Powell (D-FL) (8:37:06, Pres. Trump flashback)(8:37:45, Feldman)(8:38:20, Karlan)(8:38:50, Mick Mulvaney flashback)(8:39:19, Karlan)

    8:40:28 Rep. Veronica Escobar (D-TX) (8:41:34, Feldman)(8:43:00, Pres. Nixon and Pres. Trump flashbacks)(8:43:15, Karlan)(8:43:45, Escobar)

    8:45:04 Rep. Collins Closing remarks.

    8:55:41 Rep. Nadler Closing remarks.

  3. Epstein lived a life that being murdered or ordering someone to be murdered is common. When you run with the devil; you're going to get burnt.

  4. Investigating Biden corruption is in the interests and security of all American taxpayers and voters, way beyond being of any personal advantage to Trump who would bury Joe in any election.Joe couldn't run a bath, never mind USA.


  6. Dear America: your Democratic Party are a national disgrace that may take decades to recover, leaving your country with an ineffective opposition to hold the elected government accountable!

  7. If [they] are not scared of losing in 2020, then………
    Let the Republican Senators VOTE IN SECRET!!
    They shouldn't be scared to tell the TRUTH

  8. This an impeachment by an elected body so why are these unelected professors giving their opinions…and why in the fuck do we care what they think. These 4 are supposed experts as if they are the only ones or even the best ones. This whole thing is a joke and it's clearly a plan to help democrats win the election. This will nothing more that talking points for Democrat candidates. This is not impeachment but it is a campaign and some with tax payer dollars and should be a violation of campaign laws. This is a disgusting time in Washington

  9. Whose going to make this House accountable for wasting 3 years. The Democrats living down to their do nothing reputation.

  10. I'm getting weary of the junk language. No evidence that Trump initiated a bribe as described. What we have heard is that it was on the table from his staff. What we have is Trump refusing his staff to go ahead with what they came up with which is legal. It is legal to request updates information on a investigation of Biden and his employment positioning. In truth the fact that they are political members and running for office is irrelevant.

  11. You have no destruction of Congress when mr. Trump is ultimately the one in the hot seat. He has Hot Seat rights to defend himself and he also has freedom of speech.

  12. Is a struction of Justice to request information on the proceedings of Investigation. If these people are not rebelling against The Ballot Box and against the harmony of the elections. I would have considered laughing that off.

  13. It’s not fare for voters there’s mor democrats voters than republicans there’s 25 democrats and only 17 republicans I think that’s not fare at all

  14. SNL has to get Benedict Cumberbatch to play Noah Feldman, and have him headbang like Jerry Lee Lewis used to do at the piano.

  15. These profs are excited to have a public opportunity to set up their next book deal. Gotta get that second vacation home.

  16. Aha! So Noah thinks that the 2016 election interference and the Biden corruption are less or of no interest to USA than to Trump personally? None so blind as those who (for politically biased eyes) will not see. There's obviously no way that any of the 24 weak or looney and innumerate Dem candidates can defeat Trump in the 2020 presidential elections. Biden discussing his hairy legs is the least likely. But he should be jailed for his blatant corruption as the vice under Obama.

  17. 45: “I did, I saw it (impeachment hearings) and it’s a joke, and every bodies saying it.
    I watched.. (insert only FOX commentators here )”

  18. “Jesus went unto the mount of Olives. And early in the morning he came again into the temple, and all the people came unto him; and he sat down, and taught them. And the scribes and Pharisees brought unto him a woman taken in adultery; and when they had set her in the midst, They say unto him, Master, this woman was taken in adultery, in the very act. Now Moses in the law commanded us, that such should be stoned: but what sayest thou? This they said, tempting him, that they might have to accuse him. But Jesus stooped down, and with his finger wrote on the ground, as though he heard them not. So when they continued asking him, he lifted up himself, and said unto them, He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her. And again he stooped down, and wrote on the ground. And they which heard it, being convicted by their own conscience, went out one by one, beginning at the eldest, even unto the last: and Jesus was left alone, and the woman standing in the midst.”
    ‭‭John‬ ‭8:1-9‬ ‭KJV‬‬

  19. No political official has the right to as the question that was asked starting at time 7:13: "who did you vote for?"
    That question has no bearing on this inquiry and is down right insulting. Some of these political official should be sued for character assassination which is exactly what that GOP person tried to do!

  20. POTUS said "I'd like you to do 'US' a favor" "Us" means America. He didn't say "ME" as SUPPOSED and PRESUMED by Trump-haters in slavering lust to sink the best president ever whom they cannot beat by the ballot box.

  21. This reminded me of an episode of Cheers, where Diane and San are supposed to come up with reasons they should stay together. Bare with me, now. She come up with several pages of reasons, or so she pretends, and once she's done, Sam says "ditto". That's basically what these three dodos did. I was surprised they didn't use "what he (she) said. As for overwhelming, the only thing overwhelming is the stupidity of these jerks. Where did the Democrats find so many morons? They must have looked far and wide for them.

  22. I have to say to my family member that "Trump was NOT duly elected", the election was stolen. The people voted for Hillary Clinton, she is the duly elected!

  23. Trump did not say he only cares about the investigation of his political opponent. It could also be said Biden is not a real opponent.

  24. REP. Debbie Lesko demonstrated at 7:24:38 that no liberal can be trusted. Liberals are truely "do nothing type of persons" that can't be trusted.

  25. These hearings really are a waste of time. Neither side will convince the other, so just do the vote and get it over with.

  26. 7:10:00 How is it better to say well we don't need a reason to Impeach the President? That means you are trying to perform a coup DA!

  27. It makes me sick to hear these people talk like they havent been doing corrupt actions for generations and generations. BTW our forefathers were way more worried about the banks taking over the government and that happened long long ago. Nothing but lobbyist / banker puppets in government and the 1 person trying to stop the banks and crooked politicians is getting accused of corruption. I pray to God that all these cooked politicians, officials, judges & any other person involved in the current state of the Mafia American Government sees the full force of the judicial system or the full wrath of the American people.

  28. Pamela Karlan knows all about being barren. Pam is infertile , she cant have children . She is a barren old lesbian which explains why she is so bitchy .

  29. Whine whine whine…is that all the Republicans know how to do? Also, can they not think for themselves?? All they seem to do is parrot Trump…hoax, sham etc. If they were so confident Trump had done nothing wrong why then do they not produce Mulvaney, Pomeo etc and even Trump himself to say so.

    These Constitutional experts are here not to tell them what the fact witnesses meant but to clarify whether what their collective testimony reveal of the President's actions constitute impeachable offences.

  30. I wish the members of Congress had to be sworn in considering the Republicans spend most of their time grandstanding and spreading lies rather than actually asking questions.

  31. Trump is so desperate! He will do anything at this point to keep from the Impeachment process. His personal attorney former Mayor of NY Rudy J. Will help bring down Trump’s Presidency by his meddlesome business and corruption in the UKraine. He has no business meddling in state department business. He is already under criminal investigation for his activities in UKraine. The feds are coming for you Mr. Rudy J.

  32. The reason this impeachment has reached such an absurd level is because it’s actually The Establishment wanting Trump out. They can’t control him and that’s unacceptable for a US President.

    Schiff just turned around and did the same thing he’s claiming Trump did when he issued a subpoena for a private citizens phone records for personal gains. And the republicans are just allowing it?? Both parties are shady.

    The Establishment is the reason no one talks about Epstein and that we are actually having an impeachment hearing where not one person was a witness to the actual impeachable offense.

  33. Has anyone asked Sondland or the others, "why did you assume there was a quid pro quo, despite not being told there was?"

    Could it be because that's how all the previous administrations had done things?

  34. 7:16:41 so, wait, is this the most abbreviated rocket docket impeachment ever? or are we burning months? 🤷🏼‍♀️

  35. They weren’t witnesses, at least three of them weren’t, what they were were three angry Trump hating hyper partisan hacks. They were nasty, stinky elitist who look down on everyone because they think they’re special. There wasn’t anything they provided that was earth shattering except, they hated Trump like all democrats. Nasty worthless hyper hacks. Screw all them.

  36. This is a perfect example of why we need the border wall… We have to stop the drugs coming over. Look at how high the Democrats are… What kind of drugs are they doing to be able to even come to the conclusions they do?

    This is why the laws regarding House and the Senate need to be changed… You can't do anything to them, because they wrote the laws… They need to be able to be thrown out. In addition if you outright lie you can be thrown out… What is he point of the house rules of they aren't enforced… And they need recall for every state not just 18. I'm really sick of this… it's the fox guarding the chicken coop.

    They don't need law professors… The Dems need English professors to teach them how to read and work on their English Comprehension.

    They bring up on how dangerous it is not to give the Ukraine any money for weapons, yet when Obama was in charge he didn't help. And they keep saying that Russia wants the Ukraine back. Well if they did, they wouldn't have stopped where they did. They stopped because they could care less about the rest of the Ukraine. They consider them backwards… kind of like we do with hillbillies. And what started it, was two things… corruption and that they wanted to pass a law that Russian wouldn't be the main language. Which started the ball rolling in the mostly Russian speaking part of the Ukraine. Kind of like if we passed a law here for Spanish to be the main language and English to be our second language, don't you think most of the U.S. would be pissed off? And in the background, you had Pro Russian agitators stirring up the pot, (like here, we have pro Dem agitators, ANTIFA, CNN's and Cuomo's heros and BLM, started due to Obama jumping the gun on who was in the wrong.) because they like Putin. Because he turned their country around, it wasn't fun living there after the collapse of Communism. So the Russians do the same thing we do… regime change. I find it hard to believe you are so closed minded and so blind to what is really going on in our country and the world. And it's not just the Dems, the Republicans are just as guilty of doing underhanded things in the past… like a big one… Halliburton…

  37. Every person in that room has used there power fro personal gain and in fact that exactly what they are doing now…This has got to be A joke….its really sad

  38. Longworth .. umm they’re constitutional lawyers who’s job is to interpret the Constitution which was written by said Framers. Give me a break at 3:50:48 🤦‍♂️

  39. Jerrold Nadler (D – New York) really did have time for an opening statement! Man knows his public speaking better than most.

  40. What is wrong with these Democrats?
    They always start with self important biographies. "My parents got up every morning and went to work……." WHO CARES!!!

    Go ahead with your sham of an impeachment but please spare us the platitudes. None of you are so important that we should care!🙄

  41. What a crock of poop! Fucking idiot schills! This is why Trump was elected and this is why he's getting reelected! The Democrat party is a party of filth!

  42. They should lower the houses Lower the water cops need to stop eating at the donut shop start helping around why we paying for

  43. Jackson-Lee has been in since the 90’s what has she done for anyone lately? Or on the past for that matter. But she has lots of homes. But hey what do I know b

  44. Interference of domestic powers, this is quite the show! And thank you representatives for wasting all of our hard earned tax money, don’t worry you guys won’t be there for long, you need to be voted out, and there definitely needs to be term limits issued like yesterday

  45. When you start researching the so called Constitutional experts you see how much more partisan and twisted this all is. Progressives with axes to grind and their own agendas to push. More of the same. So sick of this.

  46. dont let this distract you from the fact that the democrats dont care about the working class (the people who do the hard work). they gave up on them in favor of illegal immigrants, social points, and opinions. who cares about trump, hes just a dude. we had worst and loved them (kennedy almost started WW3 and constantly was an idiot when it came to handling the situation) we had obama, we had way worse. i just dont care anymore and i want the hard workers of america that keep it afloat to be cared for. they arent anymore, and the democrats who used to care for them have betrayed them. republicans are no different. they stick like glue on any topic of argument. look at the nixon trials. THEY started this split and fiasco. they betrayed the foundation of the congress, and now the democrats are doing it too.

    democrats betrayed the people
    republicans betrayed the congress

    now we got a split in the people because its a "feelings over facts" debate. "idealism is possible vs. realism is struggle".

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *